Ferrari 458 Italia

2009–2015·Series 458

27 sales in the last 12 months, at a median of $235,786.

Hunt this market40 cars available across vetted dealers & auctions

40 Live Listings64 Sales on Record$13.19M Sold$279,900 – $1,349,573 Asking

Live now

For sale now

40 cars for sale.

3 auctions37 dealers

3 live auctionssoonest 1d 06h 42m 49s left

Gearbox

Auctions · 3

Ending soonest

Live1d 06h
2012 Ferrari 458 Italia
27,274 mi · automatic · Lebanon, TN
Current Bid$110,000
Live1d 06h
2011 Ferrari 458 Italia
21,183 mi · automatic · Lebanon, TN
Current Bid$129,000
In person
2010 Ferrari 458 Italia
7,892 mi · automatic · Las Vegas, NV
Pre-auction estimate$475,000-$525,000Broad Arrow Auctions The Las Vegas Auction 2026 · Oct 31, 2026

Dealers and classifieds · 37

Lowest price first

Market

What it sells for

Sales in the last 12 months.

Middle half, most salesMedianLive auction nowFor sale now

The field

Filter

Color by

Coupe27 sales

median $236k$168k – $389k

$150k$200k$250k$300k$400k

Middle half, most salesMedianLive auction nowFor sale now

Over time

The median sale price of the 2009–2015 Ferrari 458 Italia over the last 12 months.

Showing the last 12 months · 28 earlier sales since 2023 on record ·

Sales over the last 12 months

Median $235,786 · middle half $213,290–$297,750 · 27 sales

Running medianMiddle half

History

Sales record

The sales, newest first

5 of 64 shown

Car

Gearbox

ITALIA2010 Ferrari 458 Italia

33,000 mi · Rosso Corsa · Automatic · OCT 15, 2026 · Bring a Trailer

Automatic

OCT 15, 2026

Bring a Trailer

$250,000

+6% vs $235,786

ITALIA2012 Ferrari 458 Italia

2,400 mi · Giallo Modena & Nero DS · Automatic · OCT 12, 2026 · Bring a Trailer

Automatic

OCT 12, 2026

Bring a Trailer

$440,000

+87% vs $235,786

ITALIA2014 Ferrari 458 Italia

12,000 mi · Argento Nurburgring · Automatic · OCT 9, 2026 · Bring a Trailer

Automatic

OCT 9, 2026

Bring a Trailer

$355,000

+51% vs $235,786

ITALIA2014 Ferrari 458 Italia

12,668 mi · Nero · Automatic · OCT 6, 2026 · Dealer

Automatic

OCT 6, 2026

Dealer

$399,000

Last ask

not a sale

ITALIA2012 Ferrari 458 Italia

16,226 mi · White · Automatic · SEP 29, 2026 · Dealer

Automatic

SEP 29, 2026

Dealer

$469,000

Last ask

not a sale

59 more sales on record. Join free to see every sale and its price.

Know the car

Buying notes

Answers

Questions buyers ask about the Ferrari 458 Italia

Answers from GarageScout's own listing and sale records.

Factory Specifications

Ferrari 458

Years: 2009-2015
Layout: Mid-engine, rear-wheel drive
Chassis: Aviation-extruded modular aluminum alloy

What is the current market price of a Ferrari 458 Italia?

Based on 27 benchmark sales recorded over the trailing 12 months on GarageScout, the median sale price for the Ferrari 458 Italia is $235,786. Current verified live asking prices range from $279,900 to $1,349,573 (median asking price: $399,000).

How many Ferrari 458 Italia examples are currently for sale?

As of October 19, 2026, there are 40 verified Ferrari 458 Italia examples listed for sale across vetted specialist dealers and auctions on GarageScout, including 3 active live auctions with open bidding.

How many Ferrari 458 Italia cars sold in the last 12 months?

GarageScout recorded 27 sales of the Ferrari 458 Italia in the trailing 12 months, counting confirmed sales only. Restomods, gearbox conversions and sales priced like deposits or placeholders are left out.

What does a Ferrari 458 Italia sell for by model year?

Median sale prices over the trailing 12 months on GarageScout, for model years with 3 or more sales: 2010 $235,786 (7 sales); 2011 $234,117 (9 sales); 2012 $278,000 (6 sales).

Where do Ferrari 458 Italia cars sell?

Of the 27 sales GarageScout recorded in the trailing 12 months, 21 on Bring a Trailer, 2 on Barrett-Jackson, 2 on Mecum, 1 on Bonhams Cars and 1 on duPont REGISTRY Live.

Where does GarageScout's Ferrari 458 Italia market data come from?

GarageScout's Ferrari 458 Italia figures come from the listings and sales it has recorded on Bring a Trailer, Mecum, Barrett-Jackson, duPont REGISTRY Live, Bonhams Cars, 3 other sites and dealer inventories. Repeat sales of one car matched by VIN count once, and a median sale price is stated only where 3 or more sales in the trailing 12 months back it.

Nearby

Other 458 markets

GarageScout beta

Request access and tell us what you are hunting. We add members on a rolling basis.

Free during beta, no card needed

458 MARKET UPDATES

Never miss the next great 458.

Fresh listings, price cuts, and what just sold. Every Thursday, free.

40 for sale$215,111 median soldSee them →

Market

What it sells for

Sales in the last 12 months.

Middle half, most salesMedianLive auction nowFor sale now

The field

Filter

Color by

Coupe27 sales

median $236k$168k – $389k

$150k$200k$250k$300k$400k

Middle half, most salesMedianLive auction nowFor sale now

Over time

The median sale price of the 2009–2015 Ferrari 458 Italia over the last 12 months.

Showing the last 12 months · 28 earlier sales since 2023 on record ·

Sales over the last 12 months

Median $235,786 · middle half $213,290–$297,750 · 27 sales

Running medianMiddle half

History

Sales record

The sales, newest first

5 of 64 shown

Car

Gearbox

ITALIA2010 Ferrari 458 Italia

33,000 mi · Rosso Corsa · Automatic · OCT 15, 2026 · Bring a Trailer

Automatic

OCT 15, 2026

Bring a Trailer

$250,000

+6% vs $235,786

ITALIA2012 Ferrari 458 Italia

2,400 mi · Giallo Modena & Nero DS · Automatic · OCT 12, 2026 · Bring a Trailer

Automatic

OCT 12, 2026

Bring a Trailer

$440,000

+87% vs $235,786

ITALIA2014 Ferrari 458 Italia

12,000 mi · Argento Nurburgring · Automatic · OCT 9, 2026 · Bring a Trailer

Automatic

OCT 9, 2026

Bring a Trailer

$355,000

+51% vs $235,786

ITALIA2014 Ferrari 458 Italia

12,668 mi · Nero · Automatic · OCT 6, 2026 · Dealer

Automatic

OCT 6, 2026

Dealer

$399,000

Last ask

not a sale

ITALIA2012 Ferrari 458 Italia

16,226 mi · White · Automatic · SEP 29, 2026 · Dealer

Automatic

SEP 29, 2026

Dealer

$469,000

Last ask

not a sale

59 more sales on record. Join free to see every sale and its price.

The sales, newest first

5 of 64 shown

Car

Gearbox

ITALIA2010 Ferrari 458 Italia

33,000 mi · Rosso Corsa · Automatic · OCT 15, 2026 · Bring a Trailer

Automatic

OCT 15, 2026

Bring a Trailer

$250,000

+6% vs $235,786

ITALIA2012 Ferrari 458 Italia

2,400 mi · Giallo Modena & Nero DS · Automatic · OCT 12, 2026 · Bring a Trailer

Automatic

OCT 12, 2026

Bring a Trailer

$440,000

+87% vs $235,786

ITALIA2014 Ferrari 458 Italia

12,000 mi · Argento Nurburgring · Automatic · OCT 9, 2026 · Bring a Trailer

Automatic

OCT 9, 2026

Bring a Trailer

$355,000

+51% vs $235,786

ITALIA2014 Ferrari 458 Italia

12,668 mi · Nero · Automatic · OCT 6, 2026 · Dealer

Automatic

OCT 6, 2026

Dealer

$399,000

Last ask

not a sale

ITALIA2012 Ferrari 458 Italia

16,226 mi · White · Automatic · SEP 29, 2026 · Dealer

Automatic

SEP 29, 2026

Dealer

$469,000

Last ask

not a sale

59 more sales on record. Join free to see every sale and its price.

Answers

Questions buyers ask about the Ferrari 458 Italia

Answers from GarageScout's own listing and sale records.

Factory Specifications

Ferrari 458

Years: 2009-2015
Layout: Mid-engine, rear-wheel drive
Chassis: Aviation-extruded modular aluminum alloy

What is the current market price of a Ferrari 458 Italia?

How many Ferrari 458 Italia examples are currently for sale?

How many Ferrari 458 Italia cars sold in the last 12 months?

What does a Ferrari 458 Italia sell for by model year?

Median sale prices over the trailing 12 months on GarageScout, for model years with 3 or more sales: 2010 $235,786 (7 sales); 2011 $234,117 (9 sales); 2012 $278,000 (6 sales).

Where do Ferrari 458 Italia cars sell?

Of the 27 sales GarageScout recorded in the trailing 12 months, 21 on Bring a Trailer, 2 on Barrett-Jackson, 2 on Mecum, 1 on Bonhams Cars and 1 on duPont REGISTRY Live.

Where does GarageScout's Ferrari 458 Italia market data come from?

Ferrari 458 Italia

For sale now

Auctions · 3

2012 Ferrari 458 Italia

2011 Ferrari 458 Italia

2010 Ferrari 458 Italia

Dealers and classifieds · 37

2012 Ferrari 458

2011 Ferrari 458 Italia

2010 Ferrari 458 Italia

2010 Ferrari 458 Italia

What it sells for

Over time

Sales over the last 12 months

Sales record

The sales, newest first

Buying notes

Questions buyers ask about the Ferrari 458 Italia

Other 458 markets

Get alerted when the next 458 hits the market

Follow the Ferrari 458 Italia market

Auctions · 3

2012 Ferrari 458 Italia

2011 Ferrari 458 Italia

2010 Ferrari 458 Italia

Dealers and classifieds · 37

2012 Ferrari 458

2011 Ferrari 458 Italia

2010 Ferrari 458 Italia

2010 Ferrari 458 Italia

What it sells for

Over time

Sales over the last 12 months

Sales record

The sales, newest first

The sales, newest first

Buying notes

Questions buyers ask about the Ferrari 458 Italia

The sales, newest first