Sold

Pl. 1 of 11

1958 Pontiac Star Chief

Mecum · Indianapolis, IN

$14,300

May 9, 2026

Original listing on Mecum

Mileage: 68,404 mi
Transmission: Automatic
Auction: Mecum Indy Auction
Closed: May 9, 2026

GarageScout Take The car Comparable prices Sightings Find another Keep exploring

Our read

GarageScout Take

/__gs-trap/p/c4f64fbc49be /__gs-canary/calibration-a7 /__gs-canary/calibration-k3

Pontiac
Star Chief
2nd Gen
Star Chief

Pl. 1 of 11

STAR CHIEF MARKET UPDATES

This one got away.

Every Thursday, get an update on the Star Chief market:

New Star Chief listings
Price cuts
What just sold

3 for sale$48,250 median soldSee them →

Email

Free. No account needed. Unsubscribe anytime.

73% below the of 9 sales in the last 12 months

STAR CHIEF MARKET UPDATES

This one got away.

Every Thursday, get an update on the Star Chief market:

New Star Chief listings
Price cuts
What just sold

3 for sale$48,250 median soldSee them →

Email

Free. No account needed. Unsubscribe anytime.

Keep exploring

This listing is closed. Keep shopping live inventory

Live same generation on GarageScout.

Live auction2d 13h 28m 50s left
1958 Pontiac Star Chief Catalina Two-Door Hardtop
Bid$1,958
50,000 mi - TMUautomatic
In-person auctionMecum Kissimmee Auction
1958 Pontiac Star Chief
Auction · Jan 7
automatic
In-person auctionMecum Dallas/Fort Worth Auction
1957 Pontiac Star Chief
Upcoming auction
automatic

See the Gen2 market→

Identity & configuration

The car

Year: 1958
Make: Pontiac
Model family: Star Chief
Generation: Gen2
Engine: 370 CI V-8
Transmission: Automatic
Mileage: 68,404 miles
Exterior: Bronze/White
Interior: Bronze/White
VIN: C858H1200

Market

Comparable prices

Star Chief

Median sold

$53,000

This car $14,300 · 73% below

9 sales · last 12 months

Sales over time

Earlier history

12-month medianMiddle halfThis car's sale $14,300

11 records · 9 sold · 2 unsold

Outcome

Car

Gearbox

Date · source

Price

vs median

1957 Pontiac Star Chief

5,693 mi · Raven Black · Automatic · Sep 25, 2026 · Mecum (opens in a new tab)

Automatic

Sep 25, 2026

Mecum (opens in a new tab)

−17% vs $53,000

1957 Pontiac Starchief 'Tri-Power'

— · Sep 5, 2026 · Kruse Auctions (opens in a new tab)

—

Sep 5, 2026

Kruse Auctions (opens in a new tab)

+69% vs $53,000

1957 Pontiac Star Chief Catalina

87,813 mi · Cordova Red/Kenya Ivory · Automatic · Jul 22, 2026 · Mecum (opens in a new tab)

Automatic

Jul 22, 2026

Mecum (opens in a new tab)

−48% vs $53,000

1957 Pontiac Star Chief Catalina

30,353 mi · Copper/White · Automatic · May 16, 2026 · Mecum (opens in a new tab)

Automatic

May 16, 2026

Mecum (opens in a new tab)

High bid · not sold

—

1957 Pontiac Star Chief

708 mi · TMU · White · Automatic · Apr 23, 2026 · Bring a Trailer (opens in a new tab)

Automatic

Apr 23, 2026

Bring a Trailer (opens in a new tab)

+15% vs $53,000

View all market records →

1–5 of 11 shown

History

Sightings

1 event

May 9, 2026, 12:00 PM UTC
Sold
$14,300 · Mecum

1958 Pontiac Star Chief
Mecum · Listing closed · 68,404 mi · May 9, 2026 · View on Mecum
Hammer price $14,300

Find another

Hunt the next one

See the Star Chief (Gen2) market →3 for sale