Sold

Pl. 1 of 24

1958 Pontiac Star Chief

Mecum · Kissimmee, FL

$64,900

Jan 9, 2026

Original listing on Mecum

Mileage: 30,820 mi
Transmission: Automatic
Auction: Mecum Kissimmee Auction
Closed: Jan 9, 2026

GarageScout Take The car Comparable prices Sightings Find another Keep exploring

Our read

GarageScout Take

/__gs-trap/p/1ec0490e-6f4 /__gs-canary/calibration-a7 /__gs-canary/calibration-k3

Pontiac
Star Chief
2nd Gen
Star Chief

Pl. 1 of 60

GarageScout tracks every Star Chief across auctions, dealers and private sales. See how this one compares →

69% above the of 6 sales in the last 12 months

Get the weekly Star Chief report: new cars for sale and what sold.

Email

Free. Track a market's prices and save cars.

The Gen2 marketSee 3 cars for sale now

Keep exploring

This listing is closed. Keep shopping live inventory

Live same generation on GarageScout.

In-person auctionMecum Kissimmee Auction
1958 Pontiac Star Chief
Auction · Jan 7
automatic
In-person auctionMecum Dallas/Fort Worth Auction
1957 Pontiac Star Chief
Upcoming auction
automatic
Live auction4d 03h 30m 39s left
1958 Pontiac Star Chief Catalina Two-Door Hardtop
Bid$1,958
50,000 mi - TMUautomatic

See the Gen2 market→

Identity & configuration

The car

Year: 1958
Make: Pontiac
Model family: Star Chief
Generation: Gen2
Body: Coupe
Engine: 370 CI V-8
Transmission: AutomaticSeller reported
Mileage: 30,820 miles
Exterior: Redwood Copper/Patina Ivory
Interior: Copper/White
VIN: P858H25415

Market

Comparable prices

Star Chief

Median sold

$38,500

This car $64,900 · 69% above

6 sales · last 12 months

Sales over the last 12 months

12-month medianMiddle halfThis car's sale $64,900

8 records · 6 sold

Outcome

Car

Gearbox

Date · source

Price

vs median

1957 Pontiac Star Chief

5,693 mi · Raven Black · Automatic · Sep 25, 2026 · Mecum (opens in a new tab)

Automatic

Sep 25, 2026

Mecum (opens in a new tab)

+14% vs $38,500

1957 Pontiac Starchief 'Tri-Power'

— · Sep 5, 2026 · Kruse Auctions (opens in a new tab)

—

Sep 5, 2026

Kruse Auctions (opens in a new tab)

+133% vs $38,500

1957 Pontiac Star Chief Catalina

87,813 mi · Cordova Red/Kenya Ivory · Automatic · Jul 22, 2026 · Mecum (opens in a new tab)

Automatic

Jul 22, 2026

Mecum (opens in a new tab)

−29% vs $38,500

1957 Pontiac Star Chief Catalina

30,353 mi · Copper/White · Automatic · May 16, 2026 · Mecum (opens in a new tab)

Automatic

May 16, 2026

Mecum (opens in a new tab)

High bid · not sold

—

1958 Pontiac Star Chief

68,404 mi · Bronze/White · Automatic · May 9, 2026 · Mecum (opens in a new tab)

Automatic

May 9, 2026

Mecum (opens in a new tab)

−63% vs $38,500

View all market records →

1–5 of 8 shown

History

Sightings

1 event

Jan 9, 2026, 1:00 PM UTC
Sold
$64,900 · Mecum

1958 Pontiac Star Chief
Mecum · Listing closed · 30,820 mi · Jan 9, 2026 · View on Mecum
Hammer price $64,900

Find another

Hunt the next one

See the Star Chief (Gen2) market →3 for sale